Board of review questions for every rank, and how to run one
More than 120 board of review questions for Tenderfoot through Eagle, grouped by what each rank asked of the Scout, then what to avoid, who sits on the board, how it decides, and how Eagle boards differ.
Checked against its sources on
After a Scout has finished the requirements for a rank, from Tenderfoot to Eagle, they sit a board of review. The Guide to Advancement says its purpose is to judge the quality of the Scout’s experience and decide whether the requirements were met, and then to encourage the Scout toward the next rank. Below are questions for each rank, then how to ask them and how to run the board.
1. Questions for each rank
Each rank’s questions start from what its requirements had the Scout do, and ask about the experience, not for a demonstration. They’re grouped by the rank’s requirement areas, then Scout spirit and what’s next. A 15-minute board has room for a handful, so each member might take a group or two and let the answers lead. The Troop Committee Guidebook has more examples.
Tenderfoot board of review questions
What the Scout did for Tenderfoot: a first night on a campout in a tent they helped pitch, helping cook a meal, knife, saw and ax care, basic first aid, 30 days of fitness practice, flag etiquette, an hour of service, and teaching the square knot with the Teaching EDGE method.
Camping and outdoor ethics
- Tell us about your first campout with the troop. What surprised you?
- How did you get your gear ready? Who helped you?
- How did your patrol do Leave No Trace on that outing?
Cooking
- Tell us about the meal you helped cook. How did it turn out?
- How does your patrol split up cooking and cleanup? Is it fair?
Tools, knots and first aid
- Tell us about when you learned how to tie a square knot. Who taught you?
- Where have you used your knots since you learned them?
- Who taught you to use a knife, saw and ax safely? What do you remember most?
- Which first aid skill was the hardest to learn? Where did you learn it?
- Have you had to use any first aid since, even something small?
Hiking and fitness
- Why do you think the troop uses the buddy system?
- Tell us about tracking your fitness for 30 days. What did you learn about yourself?
- Which test improved the most? What did you do to get there?
Citizenship, service and leadership
- What was your hour of service, and how does it relate to the Scout motto and slogan?
- Where did you learn how to handle the flag? Have you been part of a flag ceremony?
- Tell us about teaching someone the square knot. How did it go?
Scout spirit
- Which point of the Scout Law is easiest for you to live? Which is hardest?
- Tell us about a time you lived one of the points of the Scout Law at home or at school.
- What does Scout spirit mean to you?
The troop and what’s next
- What do you like best about the troop? What would you change?
- How is your patrol getting along?
- What are you looking forward to working on for Second Class?
Second Class board of review questions
What the Scout did for Second Class: five troop or patrol activities with two overnights, building a fire and lighting a stove, cooking a hot breakfast or lunch, a 5-mile hike by map and compass, the beginner swim test and water rescues, more first aid, four weeks of daily activity, a plan to earn money for something they want, two hours of service, and what to do about bullying.
Camping and outdoor ethics
- Of the troop activities you counted for this rank, which did you enjoy most?
- Tell us how you chose a patrol site. What did your patrol leader think?
- Which Leave No Trace principle does the troop follow best? Which needs work?
Fire, stoves and cooking
- Who taught you to build a fire? What was hardest about it?
- What did you cook for your patrol, and how did it turn out?
- How did you decide what to cook? Did nutrition come into it?
- Tell us about learning the bowline or the sheet bend. Have you needed either one?
Navigation and nature
- Tell us about your 5-mile hike. Who helped plan the route, and how did it go?
- Was there a moment on the hike when the map and compass really mattered?
- Which of the wild animals you found was the most interesting?
Aquatics and first aid
- How did you prepare for the swim test?
- Where did you learn the water rescues, and who taught you?
- Which of the first aid skills for this rank do you think matters most on a campout?
Fitness and health
- Tell us about your four weeks of daily activity. What kept you going?
- Tell us about the program on drugs, alcohol and tobacco. What did you and your family talk about?
Citizenship and money
- Where was the flag ceremony you took part in? What was your part?
- What did you save up for? Tell us how your plan to earn the money went.
- What did comparing prices at three places teach you?
- What was your service project, and who did it help?
Staying safe
- What did you learn about bullying? What would you do if you saw it in the troop?
Scout spirit
- Which points of the Scout Law did you think about for this rank, and why those?
- Tell us about a time it was hard to do the right thing.
- How do you show Scout spirit at troop meetings?
The troop and what’s next
- What’s the best thing your patrol has done together?
- If you could plan the next campout, where would the troop go?
- What’s your plan for First Class?
First Class board of review questions
What the Scout did for First Class: ten activities with three overnights, planning and budgeting a patrol menu and serving as cook, lashings, a 1-mile orienteering course and GPS, plants and weather, the swimmer test and a line rescue, a home emergency plan, a talk about a citizen’s rights and obligations, an environmental issue in their community, three hours of service, and inviting someone to Scouting.
Camping and cooking
- Which campout taught you the most, and why?
- Tell us about the campout where you were cook. What went well, and what would you change?
- How did you plan the menu and the budget? Did you stay within it?
- What was it like to supervise your assistant cooks?
Tools, navigation and nature
- What did you build with your lashings? Who taught you?
- Tell us about the orienteering course. What did you learn from it?
- Where have you used GPS or a navigation app since this rank?
- How do you check the weather before an outing? Has it ever changed a plan?
Aquatics, first aid and emergencies
- Tell us about the swimmer test. Was it a challenge?
- Where did you learn the line rescue? What was it like to practice?
- Tell us how you made your family’s emergency plan. Did it change anything at home?
Fitness
- How have you kept active since Second Class? What’s your goal now?
Citizenship and community
- Who did you talk with about the rights and obligations of a citizen? What did you learn?
- What environmental issue did you look into, and what did you share with your patrol?
- How did you cut down on the trash you produce on outings?
- Tell us about your three hours of service. How does it relate to the Scout Law?
Leadership and recruiting
- Who did you invite to Scouting? What did you tell them about the troop?
- Did they come to anything? How did that feel?
Scout spirit
- Which points of the Scout Law did you think about for this rank? Tell us about one in action.
- How has Scouting changed you since you joined?
The troop and what’s next
- Now that you’ve reached First Class, how will you help newer Scouts get there?
- What would you like to do next in Scouting: a position, a merit badge, high adventure?
- What’s one thing you’d change about the troop?
Star board of review questions
What the Scout did for Star: four months active as a First Class Scout, six merit badges (four of them Eagle-required), six hours of service, four months in a position of responsibility, and the personal safety exercises with a parent or guardian.
Being active in the troop
- What has the troop been like for you since First Class?
- Which outing or event since then stands out, and why?
Position of responsibility
- Tell us about your position of responsibility. What did you actually do?
- What went well, and what was hard?
- What did you learn about leading other Scouts?
- What advice would you give the next Scout in that position?
Merit badges
- Which merit badge was the most work, and was it worth it?
- Which one did you enjoy most? Did a counselor make it special?
- Which Eagle-required badges have you finished? How did they go?
Service
- Tell us about your service hours. Which project mattered most to you?
- What did you learn about your community from your service?
Scout spirit
- How do you live the Scout Oath at school or at home?
- Tell us about a time you showed Scout spirit when nobody asked you to.
The troop and what’s next
- How do you help the younger Scouts in the troop?
- What is the troop doing well? What could it do better?
- What are you aiming for next in Scouting?
Life board of review questions
What the Scout did for Life: six months active as a Star Scout, five more merit badges (11 in all), six hours of service with at least three of them conservation work, six months in a position of responsibility, and teaching a younger Scout a set of rank skills with the Teaching EDGE method.
Being active in the troop
- How has your place in the troop changed since you made Star?
- How do you balance Scouting with everything else in your life?
Position of responsibility
- Tell us about your position of responsibility since Star. What are you proudest of?
- How has the way you lead changed since Star?
- Tell us about a problem you had to solve as a leader.
Teaching
- Tell us how you taught a younger Scout with the Teaching EDGE method. How did you know it worked?
- What did teaching teach you?
Merit badges
- Which merit badge since Star taught you the most?
- Has a merit badge sparked an interest you didn’t have before?
- Which Eagle-required badges do you still need?
Service and conservation
- What conservation service did you do, and what did you take away from it?
- Tell us about another service project since Star that mattered to you.
Scout spirit
- What does Scout spirit look like for an older Scout in this troop?
- Which point of the Scout Law do you think about most as a leader?
What’s next
- Have you started thinking about an Eagle project?
- What do you hope to leave behind in this troop?
Eagle board of review questions
What the Scout did for Eagle: six months active as a Life Scout, 21 merit badges, six months in a position of responsibility, and planning and leading their Eagle Scout service project. Their Scout spirit requirement also asks how the Scout Oath and Law will guide their life in the future. Before the board, the Scout attaches a statement of ambitions and life purpose to the Eagle Scout Rank Application, along with leadership positions held outside the troop. Both make good starting points. Check your council’s procedures for how its Eagle boards run (see section 7).
The Eagle project
- Tell us about your Eagle project. How did you choose it?
- What was hardest to lead, and what would you do differently?
- How did you organize your volunteers? What did you learn about getting people to follow through?
- What did the organization you helped think of the result?
Ambitions and life purpose
- We read your statement of ambitions and life purpose. Tell us more about it.
- How has Scouting shaped your plans?
- Where do you see yourself in ten years?
Leadership
- Which of your leadership positions taught you the most, in the troop or outside it?
- Tell us about a Scout you mentored.
- What makes a good leader, in your experience?
Merit badges
- Which merit badge had the biggest effect on you?
- Which Eagle-required badge was the biggest challenge?
Scout spirit and the future
- How will the Scout Oath and Law guide you in the future?
- What does being an Eagle Scout mean to you?
- How has Scouting changed you since you joined?
Giving back
- How do you plan to stay involved with Scouting?
- What would you tell a Scout who’s thinking about quitting?
2. How to ask, and what to avoid
A board of review must never become an examination. Ask where the Scout learned a skill, who taught them and what they got out of it, not to show it again. The Guide to Advancement’s own example: “Tell us about when you learned how to tie a square knot” is fine, but handing the Scout a rope is not. Questions about requirements stick to the rank under review, so a Life Scout isn’t asked about Tenderfoot. Talk too about how the Scout lives the Scout Oath and Law at home, at school and in the community, without expecting perfection.
Don’t ask:
- “Show us how to…” or anything that retests a skill.
- About requirements from an earlier rank.
- About uniform, dues or fundraising as a condition of passing.
- The same fixed list of every Scout. Boards should get unrehearsed answers.
3. Schedule it promptly
The date of the board of review, not a later court of honor, is the date the Scout earns the rank. That starts the clock on the next rank’s time requirements, so boards should happen as soon as Scouts are ready, or on a regular schedule. A board must be granted when a Scout believes the requirements, including the Scoutmaster conference, are done. It can’t be put off for uniform, unpaid dues, fundraising or anything beyond the requirements. If leaders think a Scout isn’t ready, they can say so and suggest what would help, but it’s the Scout’s decision to go ahead.
4. Who sits on the board
- Three to six members, all 21 or older. For Tenderfoot through Life, they’re troop committee members. If fewer than three can serve, knowledgeable parents (not the Scout’s) or other adults 21 or older can fill in, as the exception.
- Not the Scoutmaster or assistants. Unit leaders must not sit on a board for a Scout in their own troop.
- Not family. Parents, guardians and relatives can’t serve on their own Scout’s board, and the Scout and family have no say in who does.
- One member chairs. The committee decides how the chair is chosen, and the chair reports the result to the troop’s advancement coordinator.
5. Running the board
- Keep it relaxed. The Scoutmaster can introduce the Scout, and a few minutes of getting acquainted helps. The Scoutmaster may stay to observe but takes no part unless asked.
- Keep the room small. No youth observers. Parents shouldn’t attend, but if they insist after hearing why, they must be allowed to observe.
- About 15 minutes, never more than 30. A Scout up for Tenderfoot, Second Class and First Class at once gets a separate board for each, ideally with different members.
- Uniform preferred, never required. A board can’t turn a Scout away over uniform or dress as long as they’re clean and neat.
- No practice boards. They’re not allowed at any level. Leaders can tell Scouts what kinds of questions to expect.
6. Deciding
The Scout waits outside while the board talks it over, and approval must be unanimous. If the board approves, call the Scout back in and congratulate them. If it doesn’t, tell the Scout what they can do to improve, not what was said. The board can adjourn and reconvene later if the Scout agrees, ideally with the same members. Otherwise it decides then. A Scout who’s turned down must promptly get a follow-up letter explaining what to do next and how to appeal, with a copy to the council.
Notes are optional but a good idea. Keep them confidential and destroy them once the review or any appeal is done. Never record a board, by voice or video. Don’t present the rank until it’s been reported to the council in Scoutbook Plus.
7. Eagle boards are different
The council decides how Eagle Scout boards are run, whether by the troop committee or the district or council. When the troop holds one, at least one district or council representative who isn’t part of the troop must sit on it. Members are still three to six adults 21 or older, but they don’t have to be registered with Scouting America. Check your council’s procedures before scheduling one.
8. A checklist for the advancement chair
- Keep a list of Scouts close to finishing a rank, and invite them to ask for a board.
- Line up three members who aren’t the Scout’s leaders or relatives, and choose a chair.
- Book a comfortable, private-enough spot, like a side room at the meeting place.
- Confirm the Scoutmaster conference is done, and bring the Scout’s handbook or record for reference.
- Afterwards, enter the result in Scoutbook Plus and tell the Scoutmaster.
Sources
- Guide to Advancement, Section 8, Boards of Review: An Overview for All Ranks (PDF)
- Scouts BSA Rank Requirements, Scout through Eagle (PDF)
Clovehitch isn’t affiliated with Scouting America. Policies change, so check the sources for the current text.
