Scoutmaster conference questions for every rank, and how to hold one
More than 190 Scoutmaster conference questions for Scout through Eagle, grouped by what each rank asked of the Scout, then what the Guide to Advancement says: it’s not a test, when to hold it, who can, and why a Scout can’t be refused one.
Checked against its sources on
A Scoutmaster conference is a one-on-one conversation between a Scout and the Scoutmaster that is part of every rank from Scout to Eagle. Scouting America describes it as a chance to see how the Scout understands Scouting’s ideals, how they live them in daily life and in the troop, and what’s ahead in the next rank. Below are questions for each rank, then how to hold the conference.
1. Questions for each rank
These aren’t a script or a checklist, and they aren’t a retest. Each rank’s questions start from what its requirements just had the Scout do, because that’s what they’ll have stories about. They’re grouped by the rank’s requirement areas, then Scout spirit and what’s next. Nobody should get all of them: pick a handful from different groups, listen, and follow where the Scout takes it.
Scout Scoutmaster conference questions
What the Scout did for Scout: the Scout Oath, Law, motto and slogan, how the troop is led by its Scouts, the patrol method, their first knots and pocketknife safety. For many Scouts this is their first one-on-one with an adult leader, so keep it short and welcoming.
Joining the troop
- What made you want to join the troop?
- Did you know anyone here before you joined? Who have you gotten to know since?
- What did you expect Scouts BSA to be like? What’s been different?
- If you were in Cub Scouts, what’s the biggest change so far?
- What does your family think about you joining?
The Scout Oath, Law, motto and slogan
- Which part of the Scout Oath means the most to you? Which part is hardest to understand?
- Which point of the Scout Law do you think you already live well? Which one will take some work?
- What does “Be Prepared” mean to you outside of Scouting?
- Tell me about a Good Turn you did lately. Did anyone notice?
- In your own words, what is Scout spirit? Where have you seen someone in the troop show it?
- What’s the difference between the Outdoor Code and Leave No Trace, as you understand it?
The patrol and the troop
- What’s your patrol called? How did you pick the name, flag and yell?
- Who’s your patrol leader, and what have you seen them do?
- The Scouts lead this troop. What surprised you about that?
- What do you understand about how ranks and merit badges are earned?
- Is there a merit badge you’re already curious about?
First skills
- Which knot was hardest to learn, and who helped you get it?
- Where do you think you’ll first use a taut-line hitch or two half-hitches for real?
- What did you learn about using a pocketknife that you didn’t know before?
Looking ahead
- What are you most looking forward to: your first campout, summer camp, a skill?
- Is there anything about the troop nobody has explained yet?
- Is anything about campouts making you nervous? What would help?
- What’s one goal you’d like to reach by Tenderfoot, and how can I help?
Tenderfoot Scoutmaster conference questions
What the Scout did for Tenderfoot: a first night on a campout in a tent they helped pitch, helping cook a meal, knife, saw and ax care, basic first aid, 30 days of fitness practice, flag etiquette, an hour of service, and teaching the square knot with the Teaching EDGE method.
Camping and outdoor ethics
- Tell me about your first night camping with the troop. What was the best part? The hardest?
- What did you pack that you didn’t need? What do you wish you’d brought?
- How did your patrol work together pitching tents?
- Where did you see the troop following Leave No Trace on the outing? Anywhere it could do better?
- Which durable surfaces did you notice on the hike, and why do they matter?
Cooking
- Which meal did you help cook? How did it turn out?
- Why do you think everyone in the patrol should share cooking and cleanup?
- What’s it like eating together as a patrol? Does it change how the patrol gets along?
Tools, knots and first aid
- Where did you use one of your knots for real on the campout?
- Who taught you to care for a knife, saw and ax? What rule would you pass on to a new Scout?
- Which first aid skill do you think you’re most likely to need? Have you used any yet?
- Which poisonous or hazardous plants grow around here, and how did you learn to spot them?
- What’s in your personal first-aid kit now?
Hiking and staying safe
- Why does the troop use the buddy system? Has a buddy ever helped you out?
- What did you learn about what to do if you get lost?
- What did you learn about hiking safely along a road or at night?
Fitness
- How did your 30 days of fitness practice go? Which test improved the most?
- What made it hard to keep going, and what helped?
- Are you going to keep any of it up?
Citizenship and service
- Tell me about your service project. Who did it help?
- How does that service connect to the Scout motto and slogan for you?
- What did you learn about how to display and fold the flag? Where have you seen it done right, or wrong?
Leadership
- You taught someone the square knot using the Teaching EDGE method. What was it like being the teacher?
- How did you know they’d really learned it?
- Would you like to teach other skills to newer Scouts?
Scout spirit
- Which four points of the Scout Law did you talk about? Tell me about one in your everyday life.
- What does “duty to God” mean to you and your family, in your own words?
- Where have you shown Scout spirit at school or at home lately?
Looking ahead
- What are you working on next for Second Class?
- What would make your patrol’s next campout better?
- What’s one thing the troop could do that you’d really enjoy?
Second Class Scoutmaster conference questions
What the Scout did for Second Class: five troop or patrol activities with two overnights, building a fire and lighting a stove, cooking a hot breakfast or lunch, a 5-mile hike by map and compass, the beginner swim test and water rescues, more first aid, four weeks of daily activity, a plan to earn money for something they want, two hours of service, and what to do about bullying.
Camping and outdoor ethics
- Of the troop activities you’ve done so far, which was your favorite, and why?
- Tell me about the patrol site you picked. What did you look for, and did the patrol agree?
- Which Leave No Trace principle is hardest for the troop to follow? Why?
Fire, stoves and cooking
- Tell me about building your fire. What went wrong the first time, if anything?
- When do you think a fire is the right choice, and when isn’t it?
- What did you cook for breakfast or lunch on the campout? What would you change next time?
- How do you decide whether a meal is a healthy one?
- What did you learn about keeping food safe on a campout?
- Which knot, the sheet bend or the bowline, have you used for real?
Navigation
- Tell me about your 5-mile hike. Who went, and where did you go?
- Did the map and compass ever surprise you or get you turned around?
- What hazards did you think about before the hike? Did any come up?
- How would you find north today without a compass?
Nature and aquatics
- Which wild animals did you find, or find signs of? Which was the most interesting?
- How do you feel about swimming? Was the swim test easy, or something you worked at?
- What did you learn about why a reaching or throwing rescue comes before a swimming rescue?
First aid and emergencies
- Which of the “hurry cases” stuck with you most when you learned them?
- What would you do first if you came on the scene of an accident?
- How could a patrol prevent heat, cold or dehydration problems on a campout?
Fitness and health
- Four weeks of activity five days a week: what was your routine, and what made it hard?
- What’s your goal for staying active now?
- You took part in a program about the dangers of drugs, alcohol and tobacco. What did you and your family talk about afterwards?
Citizenship and money
- Tell me about the flag ceremony you took part in. Where was it?
- What did you save up for? How did your plan to earn the money go?
- Did you change the plan along the way? What did you decide to do with the money?
- Where did you find the best price, and what did comparing prices teach you?
- Tell me about your two hours of service. How do they connect to the Scout motto and slogan?
Staying safe
- What did you learn about bullying? Have you seen it happen, in Scouts or anywhere else?
- If you saw a Scout in the troop being picked on, what would you do?
- Do you know which adults you can go to in the troop if something isn’t right?
Scout spirit
- Which new points of the Scout Law did you choose this time, and why those?
- Tell me about a time this month when living the Scout Law was hard.
- How have you done your duty to God since your last rank, in your own words?
Looking ahead
- What’s left for First Class, and what’s your plan for it?
- Is there a skill you’d like to get better at before the next campout?
- How is your patrol doing? What would make it better?
First Class Scoutmaster conference questions
What the Scout did for First Class: ten activities with three overnights, planning and budgeting a patrol menu and serving as cook, lashings, a 1-mile orienteering course and GPS, plants and weather, the swimmer test and a line rescue, a home emergency plan, a talk about a citizen’s rights and obligations, an environmental issue in their community, three hours of service, and inviting someone to Scouting.
Camping and outdoor ethics
- Looking back over all your campouts, which one taught you the most?
- How does a troop campout affect the place and the other people using it? What does our troop do about that?
- How did you cut down on the trash you produce on outings? Did it stick?
Cooking
- Tell me about planning the menu. How did you work out the amounts and the budget?
- You served as cook for the patrol. What was it like to supervise your friends?
- What went wrong in the kitchen, and how did you handle it?
- What did you learn about handling meat, eggs and dairy safely on a campout?
Tools and pioneering
- What did you build with your lashings? Did it hold up?
- Which tool or knot skill do you feel most confident teaching to a younger Scout?
Navigation, nature and weather
- Tell me about the orienteering course. What was harder than you expected?
- Do you trust a map and compass or a GPS more? Why?
- Which native plants did you learn? Do you notice them now?
- How do you check the weather before a trip, and has the weather ever changed a troop plan?
- What extreme weather do we need to plan for around here?
Aquatics, first aid and emergencies
- How did the swimmer test go?
- What was the line rescue like, both as rescuer and as tender?
- Which first aid skill for this rank do you think is most important for a patrol to have?
- Tell me about the emergency plan you made for your home. Did making it change anything?
Fitness
- How did the second round of four weeks of activity compare with the first?
- What goal have you set for staying active, and how will you keep track?
Citizenship and community
- Who did you talk with about the rights and obligations of a citizen? What stuck with you?
- What environmental issue did you look into, and what could people here do about it?
- Tell me about your three hours of service. How does that service relate to the Scout Law?
Leadership and recruiting
- Who did you invite to Scouting, and how did it go?
- What do you tell a friend when they ask what Scouts is like?
- What do new Scouts need most from older Scouts in their first few months?
Scout spirit
- Which points of the Scout Law did you choose this time? Tell me about one in action.
- How has Scouting changed the way you act at school or at home since you joined?
- How have you done your duty to God since your last rank, in your own words?
Looking ahead
- You’ve finished the core outdoor skills. What do you want next: high adventure, a leadership position, merit badges?
- Which position of responsibility might you like for Star?
- Which Eagle-required merit badges have you started, or want to start?
- If it were up to you, what’s one thing you’d change about how the troop runs?
Star Scoutmaster conference questions
What the Scout did for Star: four months active as a First Class Scout, six merit badges (four of them Eagle-required), six hours of service, four months in a position of responsibility, and the personal safety exercises with a parent or guardian.
Being active in the troop
- What have the last four months in the troop been like for you?
- Which troop activity since First Class has been the best? The worst?
- How do you balance Scouting with school, sports and everything else?
Position of responsibility
- What did your position actually involve, week to week?
- What did you learn about leading people your own age?
- Tell me about a time it didn’t go well. What did you do?
- Who helped you learn the job? Who would you hand it to next?
- If you held the position again, what would you do differently?
Merit badges
- Which merit badge has been the most interesting so far, and why?
- Which was the most work? Was it worth it?
- Tell me about a merit badge counselor who made an impression on you.
- Which Eagle-required merit badges are you planning next?
Service
- Which service project since First Class has meant the most to you?
- Did any of it change how you see your community?
Personal safety
- You went through the personal safety exercises with your family. Do you know who to talk to if something ever feels wrong, in or out of Scouting?
Scout spirit
- Where have you seen the Scout Oath and Law make a difference outside Scouting?
- Which point of the Scout Law has been hardest to live lately?
- How have you done your duty to God since First Class, in your own words?
The troop and the younger Scouts
- What are the younger Scouts struggling with that the adults might not see?
- How do you help the newer Scouts in your patrol?
- What’s working well in the troop right now? What isn’t?
Looking ahead
- What are your goals for Life rank, and what’s your timeline?
- Is there a high-adventure trip or training like NYLT you’d like to do?
- What would you like to be doing in the troop a year from now?
Life Scoutmaster conference questions
What the Scout did for Life: six months active as a Star Scout, five more merit badges (11 in all), six hours of service with at least three of them conservation work, six months in a position of responsibility, and teaching a younger Scout a set of rank skills with the Teaching EDGE method.
Being active in the troop
- What have your six months as a Star Scout been like?
- Has your role in the troop changed since you made Star? How?
- How are you balancing Scouting with school, work, sports and everything else?
Position of responsibility
- What did your position involve, and what are you proudest of?
- How has the way you lead changed since Star?
- Tell me about a conflict you had to handle. What did you learn from it?
- How did you work with the senior patrol leader and the adults?
Teaching
- Which skills did you teach with the Teaching EDGE method, and to whom?
- How did you know the Scout had really learned them?
- What’s harder: doing a skill or teaching it? Why?
Merit badges
- Which merit badge since Star taught you the most?
- Has any merit badge made you think about a career or a hobby?
- Which Eagle-required merit badges do you still need, and what’s your plan for them?
Service and conservation
- What was your conservation service, and what difference did it make?
- Which service project since Star would you do again?
Scout spirit
- How do you live the Scout Oath and Law when no one from Scouting is around?
- Who in your life shows Scout spirit best, in or out of Scouting?
- How have you done your duty to God since Star, in your own words?
The Eagle project
- Have you started thinking about an Eagle project? Which causes or organizations matter to you?
- Who could you talk to about project ideas?
- What worries you about leading a project that size?
Looking ahead
- What’s your timeline for Eagle, and what could get in the way?
- What do you want the troop to look like when you age out?
- How can I help you between now and Eagle?
Eagle Scoutmaster conference questions
What the Scout did for Eagle: six months active as a Life Scout, 21 merit badges, six months in a position of responsibility, and planning and leading their Eagle Scout service project. Their Scout spirit requirement also asks how the Scout Oath and Law will guide their life in the future. That last part makes a natural thread for this conversation. The Scoutmaster can’t require the project workbook, the rank application or the statement of ambitions before holding this conference.
The Eagle project
- Tell me about your project from the start. How did you choose it?
- What was the hardest part to lead? What would you do differently?
- How did you handle volunteers who didn’t show up, or didn’t do what you asked?
- What did the organization you helped say about the result?
- What did you learn about planning that you’ll use again?
Leadership
- Which of your positions of responsibility taught you the most?
- How has the way you lead changed since you joined the troop?
- Who have you mentored? How are they doing now?
Merit badges
- Which merit badge changed the way you think about something?
- Which Eagle-required badge was the hardest for you, and why?
- Has a merit badge pointed you toward a career or a lifelong interest?
Scout spirit and the future
- What does being an Eagle Scout mean to you, beyond the badge?
- How do you think the Scout Oath and Law will guide you after Scouting?
- Which point of the Scout Law will matter most to you as an adult?
- How has your understanding of duty to God grown since you joined, in your own words?
Ambitions and life purpose
- What are your ambitions after high school?
- How has Scouting shaped them?
- What kind of person do you want to be in ten years?
Giving back
- How do you want to stay involved with the troop or with Scouting?
- What advice would you give a Scout who just crossed over?
- What should the troop keep doing, and what should it change, for the Scouts coming after you?
Two questions work at any rank: “What’s one thing the troop could do better?” and “What’s your next goal, and how can I help?”
2. It’s a conversation, not a test
The Guide to Advancement is clear: a Scout must take part in a conference, not “pass” one, and it isn’t a retest of requirements already signed off. It’s a time to talk about ambitions, life purpose and goals, to offer counsel, and to hear what the Scout thinks of the troop’s program. Unfinished work, and why it’s unfinished, can be part of the conversation too.
3. When to hold it
It makes sense to hold the conference once the other requirements are nearly done, and part of it can be confirming they are. But it doesn’t have to be the last step before the board of review. Holding it earlier helps Scouts on a tight schedule before their 18th birthday. Some Scoutmasters hold more than one along the way, and any of them counts toward the requirement as long as it was a substantial conversation.
4. Who holds it, and where
- The Scoutmaster, usually. If the Scoutmaster is away for a long time, or the troop is large enough that Scouts would wait, the Scoutmaster can designate an assistant Scoutmaster who is 21 or older.
- Your own child. Scoutmasters may hold conferences with their own children or relatives, but the Guide to Advancement highly recommends handing those to an assistant Scoutmaster over 21.
- Face to face. Conferences are meant to be personal and individual. Virtual ones are allowed only when circumstances rule out meeting in person.
- With the right privacy. Parents or other Scouts within earshot can change what a Scout says, so the Guide to Advancement asks for a level of privacy acceptable under Youth Protection rules. Check the Barriers to Abuse for what that means where you meet.
5. A Scout can’t be refused one
Unit leaders don’t have the authority to deny a timely conference when a rank requires one. For Eagle, the Scoutmaster can’t require the project workbook, the rank application or the statement of ambitions before holding it. If a conference is refused, a Scout who believes everything else is done can still ask for a board of review.
6. A checklist
- Before: look over the Scout’s progress, note anything worth celebrating, and pick a time and place that meets Youth Protection rules.
- During: let the Scout do most of the talking. Agree on a goal or two for the next rank.
- After: record the conference in Scoutbook, pass along any program feedback to the patrol leaders’ council, and let the advancement chair know the Scout is ready for a board of review.
Sources
- Guide to Advancement, Section 4, topic 4.2.3.5 Unit Leader (Scoutmaster) Conference (PDF)
- Scoutmaster Conference, Scouting America Troop Leader Resources
- Scouts BSA Rank Requirements, Scout through Eagle (PDF)
- Youth Protection and Adult Leadership, Guide to Safe Scouting
Clovehitch isn’t affiliated with Scouting America. Policies change, so check the sources for the current text.
